The Futurist and the Astrologer Walk Into a Room...
Dina Carvalho argued that astrology is, in itself, a data-driven system built upon thousands of years of observed planetary cycles. The "data" in astrology is not large datasets, but the meticulously observed and mathematically governed movements of celestial bodies. This system provides a unique and quantifiable "temporal context" that, Dina says, rather than competing with foresight, complements it.
Astrology, as an applied science, is reframed from a system for psychological profiling or fortune-telling (which Carvalho dismisses as a "1900s invention") to a tool focused on timing events and giving foresight to outcomes in real life by tracing the motion of planets around earth. The relevance of an event, and its future outcome, can be drastically altered by the specific moment it occurs. This is illustrated by everyday examples: a political announcement has a different temporal context and impact before an election versus in an off-season, just as launching a winter clothing line in autumn leverages the temporal context of the cold season for a far greater impact than a summer launch. Astrological timing, therefore, offers a method for identifying the optimal moment to act, a crucial missing element in strategic planning and futures work.
A fundamental divergence between the two fields arises on the issue of certainty versus possibility. Futures studies embraces scenarios and possibilities, not certainties, viewing prediction as a fool’s errand. Carvalho, however, asserts that planetary timing is predictive foresight. She maintains that because planetary cycles are very steady in motion and very predictable, there is no ambiguity; the timing of key events can be plotted "with certainty, in advance."
The only way ambiguity enters astrological practice, according to Carvalho, is if the "seed date" or original moment of intention is incorrect or unknown. This forms the potential for a symbiosis: while the astrologer can provide the when, the futurist, with their broad landscape of events, data-driven analysis, and understanding of society, can provide the who, what, where and why: context, the story, and the human element. Carvalho suggested the astrologer/futurist relationship might thrive if the astrologer provides the timeline and the futurist "fills it with the human lives inside of it."
The concept of timing deepens with the introduction of the Greek terms Kairos and Chronos. In futures thinking, timing is often very broad, dealing in time ranges (like decades) or long-term horizons. Astrological timing, however, utilizes Kairos and Chronos.
Kairos is qualitative. It signifies the right timing, decisive or opportune moment or volatile turning points, focusing on the quality of the moment. Identifying the Kairos allows a practitioner to act at the most favorable time to ensure the desired outcome.
Chronos is quantitative. It measures the sequence and length of time, and the duration of the event.
Carvalho told me that astrology combines these two, building a precise "Time Map" of opportune windows that are both qualitative and quantifiable. By offering this precise timing, the astrologer claims her ability to empower futures work, enabling "strategic and proactive interventions" and allowing clients to manage risk more effectively. Would this address the ambiguity that plagues many clients, bringing a sense of control to an anxious zeitgeist?
Carvalho explained astrology’s ability to conduct long-term forecasting stretching decades ahead is based on the different cycles of the planets: the "inner planets with shorter time spans give short-term foresight and the outer planets give longer-term foresight." The description of cycles resonates strongly with the futurist’s strategic observation of trends, weak signals, paradigm shifts, systemic change, historical eras, and macrotrends.
She also said that the concept of archetypes is central to interpreting these cycles; for example, the planet Mars embodies the archetype of violence, and archetypes help define the quality of the moment. This reminds me of the widely-used scenario archetypes approach in futures studies, where four generic futures (Continued Growth, Collapse, New Equilibrium, Transformation) give a story and structure to trends and signals.
Is lack of astrological timing a shortcoming of modern strategic foresight? A notable example of missed foresight is the COVID-19 pandemic. While futurists never dismissed the possibility of a pandemic, astrologers like Carvalho claim they pinpointed the timing. The conjunction of Jupiter (expansion) and Saturn (constriction) in 2020 was a signal, understood by ancient laws to indicate great changes in the world and a large shift in humanity characterized by restrictions, regulations, lockdown, vaccine regulations. This ability to time major historical shifts illustrates the potent, yet unrecognized, predictive value of the ancient system of astrology.
Astrology is ultimately understood as a predominantly predictive tool due to the steady, predictable cycles of the planets, but also reflective, providing meaning about the nature of change. This dual role is precisely what makes it appear useful: its predictive capacity aids decision-making and its reflective nature assists in sense-making.
Clearly, the overlap between the two professions is time literacy. Futurists, bringing scenarios, models, and detailed data can benefit from astrology's archetypal framing, cycles and detailed timing for, as Carvalho said, "sharpening the how and when key developments will unfold". Conversely, astrologers benefit from the futurist's detail of the landscape of events and scenario planning to map out and navigate future outcomes.
Ultimately, the argument for collaboration rests on the benefit of reduced uncertainty: combining foresight with timing enables prediction that helps to prepare, protect, and profit. The astrologer provides the timeline; the futurist provides the story to make it convincing enough to act. This synthesis suggests that a complete and robust approach to the future requires both the empirical and imaginative capacities of futures studies alongside the long-term, mathematically precise temporal framework offered by applied astrology. The integration of this ancestral wisdom into foresight may in fact offer a more nuanced, less anxious, and more strategically proactive approach to navigating the future.
It has never been lost on me that the profession of futures studies is an evolved form of divination, only with less mysticism and more personal branding. Foresight continues to accumulate academic and corporate credibility that clearly distinguish it from the occult, but futurology easily fits within the vocational category of “prophet.”
Is there common ground between foresight and astrology? What stands out to me from interacting with Dina Carvalho was the fact that our respective professions oblige us to pay careful attention to current events. In her work as an astrologer, the objective is seeking out “seed dates” and the milestones along the path to the eventual resolution of whatever storyline is playing out. In the case of futurists, we are quickly habituated to the act of scanning for signals and how they may converge as things unfold. Our shared preoccupation with news and events, and how forces systemically interconnect, is an interesting alignment. Is an astrologer’s Time Map equivalent to a futurist's trend radar, for example? The similarity is significant when you compare the image of a birth chart to the tech trends radar at the end of this post.
Another insight was along the lines of ancestral wisdom. The astrologer was adamant that her role is little more than calculation and forecasting, devoid of the human touch a futurist storyteller could convey. During this part of the conversation, the script suddenly flipped as Dina claimed astrology lacks the creativity and socio-cultural insight to fully flesh out a vision of the future; astrology can only give you dates. Instead, the astrologer suggested a futurist could bring a needed sense of human-centricity to astrological predictions.
Finally, reflecting on the experience of holding a serious conversation on futures studies and astrology, I think the foresight profession has earned enough gravitas so that it is fair and timely to explore how ancestral divination compares to futurology. To compare the ancient oracle to the modern futurist highlights the historical continuity of human curiosity about the future. Futures inquiry is ideally situated for understanding what makes it so universal.
Generative AI was used in the transcription, analysis, and composition of this content. Thanks to Dina Carvalho for her inspiration and participation in the interview and final review of this essay.
Image created with Gemini